The Reddit Community Speaks

Real New York, NY Locals Share Their Favorite Spots

When it comes to finding authentic local restaurants, there's no better source than the people who live and eat there every day. We've gathered the latest recommendations from Reddit's New York, NY community to bring you this curated list of must-try spots.

Where Locals Eat in New York, NY: Reddit’s Top Restaurant Picks

New York City, a melting pot of cultures, offers an array of dazzling dining experiences, and while the city is dotted with countless eateries, nothing beats dining where the locals love to go. Sourced from the genuine recommendations on Reddit and validated with a sprinkle of online research, this list guides you to the places cherished by New Yorkers. Whether you’re in search of the perfect slice of pizza, decadent desserts, or a high-end dining experience, read on to find out where locals really eat in NYC.

Joe's Shanghai - Chinatown

Neighborhood: Chinatown

Known For: Joe's Shanghai is famous for its mouthwatering Soup Dumplings, particularly the pork and crab versions.

Why Locals Love It: "Joe's dumplings are legendary. It’s always packed, a sign of its authenticity and quality." - Reddit user

Tips: Try to visit during non-peak times to avoid the long waits. Don’t miss out on their Scallion Pancakes, a perfect appetizer before indulging in their steaming baskets of dumplings.

Image: Joe's Shanghai Soup Dumplings

Di Fara Pizza - Midwood, Brooklyn

Neighborhood: Midwood, Brooklyn

Known For: Considered by many as the best pizza in New York, Di Fara is renowned for its classic Neapolitan pizza, crafted with ingredients imported from Italy.

Why Locals Love It: "It’s worth every minute of the wait. The pizza is out of this world — that magic touch of snipping fresh basil on top makes all the difference." - Reddit comment

Tips: Di Fara is notorious for its long lines and wait times. Go early or on a weekday to catch a shorter queue and witness the maestro, Dom DeMarco, in action himself.

Image: Di Fara Classic Pizza

Absolute Bagels - Upper West Side

Neighborhood: Upper West Side

Known For: This humble bagel shop is a hotspot for some of the best bagels in NYC, with a wide variety of spreads and a lively, local atmosphere.

Why Locals Love It: "Absolute Bagels has that perfect chewy texture that you crave in a New York bagel. It’s a tiny spot bustling with energy and fresh bagels out the oven!" - Reddit user

Tips: The line can stretch out the door during mornings, especially weekends. Try their everything bagel with lox spread for a quintessential NY breakfast.

Image: Absolute Bagels Spread

Katana Kitten - West Village

Neighborhood: West Village

Known For: Known for its unique blend of American and Japanese cocktail techniques, Katana Kitten serves up some of the most innovative cocktails in the city.

Why Locals Love It: "Their Highball is something I still dream about. The ambiance is just as incredible as their drinks." - Reddit discussion

Tips: Don’t miss their happy hour specials. The bar can get crowded, so consider off-peak hours for a more intimate experience.

Image: Katana Kitten Cocktails

The Halal Guys - Multiple Locations

Neighborhood: Famous cart located at 53rd St & 6th Ave, with multiple storefronts across the city.

Known For: Pioneering halal street food in NYC, they offer addictive halal platters of chicken and gyro over rice, garnished with their famous white and red sauces.

Why Locals Love It: "Absolutely addictive, and perfect for any time. That white sauce is legendary!" - Reddit comment

Tips: The original cart at 53rd and 6th has a special charm and often a different taste than the storefronts. Visit after dark for the true NYC street food experience.

Image: The Halal Guys Platter

Concluding Thoughts:

Exploring where locals eat in New York is not just about satisfying your palate; it’s about experiencing the authentic vibe and culture of this vibrant city. Each restaurant listed here isn't just a place to eat; it's a destination offering a piece of New York's heart and soul. So next time you’re in the Big Apple, skip the tourist traps and dine where the locals do. Whether it's biting into a crunchy slice of pizza, sipping a meticulously crafted cocktail, or devouring a plateful of steaming hot dumplings, these favorite local haunts promise an unforgettable New York gastronomic adventure.

Found Your Next Favorite Spot?

Join the conversation on Reddit and share your own New York, NY restaurant recommendations.

Visit r/NewYork,NY on Reddit