Reddit's Local Favorites: Where to Eat in New York

The Reddit Community Speaks

Real New York Locals Share Their Favorite Spots

When it comes to finding authentic local restaurants, there's no better source than the people who live and eat there every day. We've gathered the latest recommendations from Reddit's New York community to bring you this curated list of must-try spots.

Unearthing Local Gems: New York's Top Eateries According to Reddit

New York City, a sprawling metropolis, not only takes the crown for its iconic skyline but also wears a culinary crown studded with diverse dining experiences. It's no secret that locals have the inside scoop on where to eat, and Reddit has become a treasure trove of genuine local recommendations. If you are looking to bypass the tourist traps for some authentic, local-approved gastronomy, this guide shares highly recommended spots across the boroughs, detailing why they remain neighborhood favorites.

---

Little Collins – Midtown East

• Known for: Melbourne-inspired café culture, standout espresso, and artisanal sandwiches
• Local Insight: Redditors praise its sophisticated, yet cozy atmosphere ideal for enjoying a quality cup of coffee. "Perfect spot for a flat white and some avocado smash."
• Insider Tip: It's often busy in the morning, so try visiting mid-afternoon for a quieter experience.

Ittadi Garden and Grill – Jackson Heights

• Known for: Authentic Bangladeshi street food-like fare in a laid-back setting
• Local Insight: Praised for its traditional flavors, locals recommend Ittadi for anyone wanting to explore Bangladeshi cuisine. "Authentic taste that takes me back to Dhaka.", shares a Reddit user.
• Insider Tip: Try their famed biryani and the tehari, which are noted must-haves.

Baba’s Pierogies – Gowanus

• Known for: Handmade pierogies, both traditional and with a modern twist
• Local Insight: "Simply the best pierogies in NYC, with both classic and inventive fillings," comment enthusiasts on Reddit.
• Insider Tip: Their bacon cheddar and jalapeño pierogies are a must-try for a zesty treat.

Al-Sham Restaurant – Astoria

• Known for: Authentic Middle-Eastern cuisine, particularly Syrian and Lebanese dishes
• Local Insight: Redditors commend its genuine approach to shawarma and other staples. "Closest to the real taste of the Middle East in NYC."
• Insider Tip: The mixed grill gives a sampling of different meats, perfect for first-timers.

Joy Luck Restaurant – Chinatown

• Known for: Classic Cantonese dim sum and family-style dining
• Local Insight: Redditors highlight the traditional dim sum carts and bustling atmosphere as part of the authentic experience.
• Insider Tip: Visit during the weekday mornings to avoid the typical weekend crowds.

Sahadi’s – Brooklyn Heights

• Known for: A Middle-Eastern grocer with an impressive selection of prepared foods and bulk ingredients
• Local Insight: Favored for its fresh and flavorful offerings, locals describe it as "a slice of Middle-Eastern heaven in Brooklyn."
• Insider Tip: Don’t miss their hummus and freshly baked pita bread; perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.

Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana – Upper West Side

• Known for: Authentic Mexican fares such as tacos, enchiladas, and massive burritos
• Local Insight: Known in the Reddit community for its authenticity and cozy atmosphere. "A hidden gem for Mexican cravings,” confirms a local.
• Insider Tip: Their horchata is homemade and a must-try alongside any spicy dish.

La Morada – Mott Haven

• Known for: Oaxacan specialties and noteworthy moles
• Local Insight: La Morada is often celebrated on Reddit for its family-run, authentic approach to Oaxacan cuisine.
• Insider Tip: The mole negro is a standout dish, rich and complex in flavor.

---

Eager to explore New York through its flavors? This list navigates through some of the city’s culinary delights chosen by those who know it best: the locals. Beyond the bustling tourist pathways lies a world of exquisite eats ready to satiate appetites for authenticity and quality. As you embark on this tastebud-led adventure through the Big Apple, remember that each meal is a chapter in New York’s rich cultural narrative. Happy dining!

Found Your Next Favorite Spot?

Join the conversation on Reddit and share your own New York restaurant recommendations.

Visit r/NewYork on Reddit